Copyright infringements and warning letters – enforcing claims, defending against claims
Works are copied, published without a licence or used beyond the agreed scope. For rights holders, swift action and a robust body of evidence are then crucial. For those who have received a warning letter, the question arises as to which claims are justified and to what extent.
Our solicitors and specialist copyright lawyers represent both sides, both out of court and in court.
Inquiry Website
You have further questions about our consulting services? Talk to us or send us an e-mail.
You can also send us a message using the contact form below. If you wish, we can also call you back.
Claims in the event of a copyright infringement
The rights holder may demand an injunction and the removal of the infringing material (§ 97 Abs. 1 UrhG), damages in the event of fault (§ 97 Abs. 2 UrhG) and information regarding the scope and origin of the use (§ 101 UrhG). In addition, the rights holder is entitled to reimbursement of the costs of the warning letter and, in certain circumstances, the destruction or recall of infringing copies (§ 98 UrhG). The rights holder may calculate the damages on the basis of the lost licence fee, the infringer’s profit or their actual loss.
Enforcing rights through a cease-and-desist letter and an interim injunction
We document the infringement in a manner that preserves evidence, identify the responsible party and, where necessary, issue a warning letter. In cases where the licensing situation is unclear, a so-called authorisation enquiry may also be appropriate.
In urgent cases where an infringement must be brought to an end as quickly as possible to prevent further damage, an interim injunction is the preferred course of action. This requires swift action, as the courts may rule that the matter is no longer urgent after just a few weeks.
Receiving a warning letter: Be sure to check it carefully
A warning letter sets short deadlines. Do not let them lapse, but do not sign the enclosed cease-and-desist declaration without checking it first. Pre-formulated declarations often go beyond the specific infringement. We check whether the party issuing the warning letter actually holds the relevant rights, whether the warning letter meets the statutory formal requirements, whether an infringement has occurred, and whether the claims for damages and reimbursement of costs are set at a reasonable level. If the warning letter is justified, we recommend and draft a modified declaration of discontinuance and, where appropriate, conduct settlement negotiations.
Legal proceedings
If the dispute cannot be settled out of court, our copyright solicitors will represent you before the copyright divisions of the regional courts and the higher regional courts, in summary proceedings and in the main proceedings. Before taking any action, we assess the litigation risk and costs and examine whether a settlement would be more economically viable.
When you contact us, please send us the cease-and-desist letter with all attachments or evidence of the infringement. We will get back to you as soon as possible.
Your partners
Lawyer Christian Röhl, LL.M.
Certified Intellectual Property Lawyer
Partner
Lawyer Patrick Richnow, LL.M.
Certified Intellectual Property Lawyer
Senior Associate
Lawyer Jan Haßold, LL.M.
Specialized in copyright and media law
Salary Partner
FAQ – Frequently asked questions about copyright infringements and warning letters
Respond within the specified time limit, but only after you have checked the matter. Have the warning letter and the alleged infringement examined thoroughly before taking any action to remove the content or similar steps. In the event of an infringement, removal alone does not eliminate the risk of repetition; a cease-and-desist declaration subject to a penalty is required for this.
If the warning letter is justified, you must either submit a cease-and-desist declaration subject to a penalty clause or accept that the cease-and-desist claims will be enforced through the courts. You are not bound by the wording of the other party’s cease-and-desist declaration.
Usually as a notional licence fee. The decisive factor here is what reasonable contracting parties would have agreed for the specific use in question. Alternatively, the rights holder may claim the infringer’s profits or their actual loss.
Legal fees are based on the value of the claim. For private individuals who have not used a work in a professional or commercial capacity, this is generally capped at 1,000 euros (§ 97a Abs. 3 UrhG).
Liability for injunctive relief and removal exists under § 99 UrhG. Whether recourse can be sought against the agency depends on the terms of the contract.
In principle, three years from the end of the year in which the rights holder became aware of the infringement and the infringer. However, the rights holder may still claim the lost licence fee up to ten years after the infringement. If the use continues for a longer period, the limitation period runs separately for each day.